How different can a film be from its source material while still retaining its core identity? Bong Joon-ho's Mickey 17, based on Edward Ashton's novel Mickey7, provides a fascinating case study in adaptation, showcasing a myriad of shifts in character, plot, and overall tone, making it a unique cinematic experience.
The anticipation surrounding Mickey 17, starring Robert Pattinson, has ignited a flurry of discussions, especially among those familiar with the book. While both the film and the novel explore the concept of a disposable clone, Mickey Barnes, navigating the treacherous landscape of duty and survival, they diverge dramatically, revealing the artistic choices of a director renowned for his distinct vision. Mickey 17 premiered at Berlinale on 15 February, and it released in South Korea on 28 February, setting the stage for global discussions on its adaptation.
| Aspect | Mickey7 (Novel) | Mickey 17 (Film) |
|---|---|---|
| Author | Edward Ashton | Directed by Bong Joon-ho |
| Publication Date | 2022 | (Film) 2024 (Anticipated) |
| Core Premise | Disposable clone on a dangerous mission | Disposable clone on a dangerous mission |
| Main Character | Mickey Barnes | Mickey Barnes |
| Key Themes | Identity, immortality, survival, unglamorous immortality | Identity, immortality, survival (explored through a different lens) |
| Notable Characters (Book) | Mickey, Nasha, Timo, Marshall, Ylfa | Mickey, Nasha, Timo, Marshall, Ylfa |
| Notable Cast (Film) | Robert Pattinson (Mickey), Naomi Ackie (Nasha), Steven Yeun (Timo), Mark Ruffalo (Marshall), Toni Collette (Ylfa) | Robert Pattinson (Mickey), Naomi Ackie (Nasha), Steven Yeun (Timo), Mark Ruffalo (Marshall), Toni Collette (Ylfa) |
| Major Plot Points | Specific details vary, but includes deadly viruses, killer caterpillars, sautéed crickets, and a murderous clone | Details are being withheld but the movie significantly changed the plot |
| Genre | Sci-fi adventure, black comedy | Sci-fi adventure, black comedy (with a Bong Joon-ho touch) |
| Overall Tone | Reported as a dark comedy | Changes being made to the original tone |
| Key Differences Noted | Character and plot details altered | Character and plot details altered |
| Reference | Goodreads.com (Mickey7) | IMDB.com (Mickey 17) |
The genesis of Mickey7 stems from Edward Ashton's contemplation of an unglamorous immortality. This original concept led him to explore the realities of being a disposable clone, a concept expanded with the challenges of surviving harsh conditions and dealing with the ethical dilemmas of a future where human life is, at least in the eyes of the corporation that hires clones, expendable. This contrasts with the typical depiction of Vampires and other immortal characters that are more glamorous. The book dives deep into the values of identity, immortality, and humanity's quest for survival in the future, creating a dark comedy that captivates its reader.
The plot, as adapted, revolves around Mickey Barnes, an Expendable – a clone designated for hazardous tasks. The source material provided Bong Joon-ho a foundation. However, the film appears to diverge significantly in its adaptation, and according to preliminary reports, the film departs considerably from the narrative. The core concept is maintained, yet the alterations are significant enough to give the impression that the film is less a direct adaptation and more a re-imagining of the source material. The director's distinct style often incorporates social commentary and character-driven narratives, suggesting that the film will delve deeper into the thematic elements of the novel.
Edward Ashton's novel has received praise for its imaginative world-building and the engaging story of Mickey Barnes. However, the process of adapting a novel to film inevitably involves choices, from character development to plot restructuring. The movie is based on the novel Mickey7 by Edward Ashton, published in 2022. The filmmakers have, with each creative decision, charted a different course. With a cast that includes Robert Pattinson, Steven Yeun, and others, the film promises a unique cinematic vision.
The adaptation process has led to changes, which has made it difficult to call the movie a true adaptation of its source material. While the film's creators have stayed true to the core concept, the characters, plot details, and overall tone suggest that Mickey 17 will be a distinct work of art. While both versions follow Mickey Barnes, an Expendable caught between duty and survival, they take wildly.
